I know there's still a good three weeks of 2003 left, but I had a hankerin' to break out with one of those purely subjective year-end lists that we all love so much. Not all of these are in fact from 2003 -- there might be a 2002 here and there, but if it's reasonably new and got the play, well then I say it's fair game for my list.
Top 10 of 2003 (in no particular order)
» The Constantines, "Shine a Light"
OK, this list may not be in any particular order, but I think I'd have to say The Constantines are my breakout band of 2003. Smart, tense playing, good melodies, husky vocals celebrating the city's dark beauty, a revival-esque presentation... it all comes together as far as I'm concerned. Sub Pop was smart to snatch up these guys from up there in Canadia.
» Q and Not U, "Different Damage"
This is one of those 2002 releases that I keep turning back to. These three guys are carrying the DC rock torch as well as any of their many progenitors ever did, and their live show is killer.
» Minus the Bear, "Highly Refined Pirates"
I'm a sucker for tense, smart, technical, melodic indie rock in the vein of Jawbox and Braid, and this band is exactly that. Technically more so, if you factor in all the insanely complex finger-tapping that guitarist Dave Knudson lays in. Excellent driving music.
» The Gossip, "Movement"
Musically, this band is good enough for the Kill Rock Stars sound, meaning they're somewhat sloppy, their drummer is little more than sufficient, and they have no bassist -- but by God can frontwoman Beth Ditto belt it out. She's modern legit-rock's answer to Arethra Franklin, as far as I'm concerned. Major, major talent right there, on record and even more, on stage. And her thick Arkansas accent proves she ain't fakin' it, neither.
» Coheed and Cambria, "In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3"
I have to give this band respect for playing music true to their influences, even if those influences aren't "cool" bands like Velvet Underground or Joy Division. Nay, this band is the product of youths spent air-drumming to the likes of Rush, Voivod and other prog/concept bands, with a dash of true hardcore roots -- Bad Brains and Into Another are definitely in the recipe as well. Gotta love that.
» Elliott Smith, "Division Day/No Name #6" 7"
Rest in Peace. I truly believe that Elliott Smith was every bit the musical talent of Neil Young, Springsteen, Nick Drake, even Lennon. The home-recorded acoustic guitar intro to "No Name #6" is nothing short of perfection.
» Strike Anywhere, "Exit English"
More melodic, slower, a teensy bit less punk than 2001's excellent "Change is a Sound," but no less politically outspoken or fierce in its message. This is American hardcore at its finest.
» The Life and Times, "The Flat End of the Earth EP"
Any regular reader of redshifter.org knows I was a big fan of Shiner's heavy melody and surgically precise delivery. After Shiner's demise, frontman Allen Epley formed The Life and Times. While his new band may not be the sludgy juggernaut that Shiner was, the EP exhibits just as much songwriting proficiency, and when they let it loose, they do so with just as much aplomb as we'd all hope. Mr. Epley really prefers to work with drummers who hit like Bonham, and seeing TLAT's Mike Myers play live had me scraping my jaw off the floor more than once. I look forward to this band's debut full-length.
» Darkest Hour, "Hidden Hands of a Sadist Nation"
Yes, it is possible to be a great band from DC and not be under the Dischord umbrella. The metal chops on this record are so kick-ass, the vocals so unintelligibly guttural, the drums so relentlessly fast. Many a time have I raised a fist to Darkest Hour while I blast them in my headphones at work, only to turn and see a puzzled mechanical engineer staring at me like I sprouted horns.
» Aloha, "Sugar"
Another 2002 release, but it's so damn good that I still have to listen to it end-to-end at least once a week. That says a lot. Tension/release, jazzy rock with percussion and vibraphone. Very much awaiting their return to the studio, which is said to be in the plans for '04.
Honorable Mentions
While not the "best of," I've been known to spin these with some frequency.
» The New Pornographers, "Electric Version"
There are some really great songs on this record -- enough to make it an honorable mention -- and there are also several more that leave me flat. The LP starts out with a bang, but midway through the record I'm usually over it and look for something else.
» Paloalto, "Heroes and Villains"
There are some pretty good songs on here, and if you like the UK band Travis then you'll definitely like the songwriting on this record -- it's virtually identical. Producer Rick Rubin makes the record sound damn good, at least.
» Rocky Votolado, "Suicide Medicine"
This dude is everything that Dashboard Confessional wants to be but isn't, other than filthy rich. Great acoustic songwriting and butter-smooth vocals. I haven't been listening to it enough to qualify for "best of" status, but it's still growing on me...
» The Shins, "Chutes Too Narrow"
I was really looking forward to their follow-up to the excellent "Oh, Inverted World," and while "Chutes" is a good record, it's just not quite as great. Yeah, there are some really good songs and James Mercer is a hell of a songwriter, but I'm just left wanting more.
» The White Stripes, "Elephant"
What the hell, there are a few jams on this record, despite the hype. I wouldn't mind seeing this band win a Grammy, I guess.